Thursday, 10 December 2015

Silver linings for patients with depression?

Volume 24, Issue 18, 22 September 2014, Pages R851–R854
  Open Archive

Summary

Depression has become one of the biggest health problems globally, but in certain places more than in others, suggesting cultural as well as biological causes. Neuroscientists are only beginning to understand underlying processes and to develop effective treatments for those cases where conventional psychotherapy and drugs fail. Michael Gross reports.

Main Text

The recent death by suicide of Hollywood actor Robin Williams triggered a global discussion about mental health, bringing out all the manifold questions, uncertainties, misconceptions and prejudices that surround problems like major depressive disorder (depression) and bipolar disorder, which is what Williams reportedly suffered from and which involves alternating phases of depression and euphoria.
By its very nature, views on a suicide in the state of depression depend on people’s philosophy and outlook on life. Reactions range from the view that depression is a deadly disease like cancer and suicide is just its fatal symptom, through to the description of suicide as an act of free will designed to escape an unbearable situation. Charities like the Samaritans and Mind have warned that the latter view, if propagated in the media, may trigger further suicides, as may the reporting of excessive detail of the ways and means employed in the act. However, with the global media competing over this exceptional story, this advice was frequently neglected in the reporting.
Melancholic mind: The artist Edvard Munch (1863–1944) suffered from severe ...
Melancholic mind: The artist Edvard Munch (1863–1944) suffered from severe anxiety and has in his work depicted various states of emotional distress, including depression: this painting is called Evening. Melancholy I. (1896). (Image: Wikipedia.)
In the wake of Williams’ death, attention turned to the broader issues of depression, which is widespread but still widely misunderstood. Major depression, according to a definition from US psychiatrist Allen Frances, “must be dense (i.e., present for most of the day, almost every day); must last at least a few weeks; and must be severe enough to cause clinically significant impairment” (quoted from Essentials of Psychiatric Diagnosis). That sounds terrifying enough to justify an urgent call to a medical practitioner, but sufferers who would need medical help are still facing unhelpful comments like “just get over it” from people who fail to understand that mental illness is just as real as physical disorders.
Mood control: Neurobiological studies of mood disorders have linked the ...
Mood control: Neurobiological studies of mood disorders have linked the formation of neurons in the hippocampus to mood disorders such as depression. (Image: Life Science Databases (LSDB)/Wikimedia Commons.)
Such misconceptions may be part of the reason why only a minority of sufferers are actually getting the medical help they require.