Development of organic farming for the protection of water quality: Local projects in France and their policy implications

Land Use Policy

Volume 43, February 01, 2015, Pages 197-206

  (Article)

Vincent, A.^a , 

Fleury, P.^b

 

^a  ISARA-Lyon, Département ASTER (Agriculture, Systèmes alimentaires et Territoires), Laboratoire d'Etudes Rurales, Lyon, France
^b  ISARA-Lyon, Département ASTER (Agriculture, Systèmes alimentaires et Territoires), Laboratoire d'Etudes Rurales, Lyon, France 

View references (50)

Abstract

French public action privileges organic farming in areas with water quality problems as a way to prevent diffuse agricultural pollution. This article compares four projects connecting organic farming incentives with water quality protection. It aims at elucidating how concerned actors compromise with and implement public policy in locally specific ways. Our results show that these projects may come from two logics of public action. The first, supported by water-related actors, aims to improve drinking water quality and is focused on water catchments. The second is backed primarily by actors in agriculture and focuses on re-enforcing actions for the development of organic agriculture, carried out on a larger territorial scale. Actor networks involved in the projects differ according to local contexts, project backers, and objectives. They become more complex over time, leading actors for water, organic agricultural development, and economic production chains to work together. Actors' visions and referentials change, influencing the projects' initial objectives. The conclusion discusses such projects' relevance and limits. © 2014.

Author keywords

Actor networks; Organic farming; Project dynamics; Public policy; Water quality

Indexed keywords

GEOBASE Subject Index: agricultural development; agricultural economics; agricultural policy; incentive; organic farming; policy approach; project assessment; water quality

Regional Index: France

ISSN: 02648377Source Type: Journal Original language: English

DOI: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2014.10.020Document Type: Article

Publisher: Elsevier Ltd

References (50)

View in search results format

• Page
 
• • Export |
  • Print |
  • E-mail |
  • Create bibliography

• 
  1

  Andersson, I., Petersson, M., Jarsjö, J.

  Impact of the European Water Framework Directive on local-level water management: Case study Oxunda Catchment, Sweden
  (2012) Land Use Policy, 29 (1), pp. 73-82. Cited 14 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2011.05.006
  
• 
  2

  Barataud, F., Aubry, C., Wezel, A., Mundler, P.

  Management of drinking water catchment areas in cooperation with agriculture and the specific role of organic farming. Experiences from Germany and France
  (2014) Land Use Policy, 36, pp. 585-594. Cited 4 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2013.10.010
  
• 
  3

  Barataud, F., Durpoix, A., Mignolet, C.

  Broad analysis of French priority catchment areas: A step toward adaption of the Water Framework Directive?
  (2014) Land Use Policy, 36, pp. 427-440. Cited 2 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2013.09.010
  
• 
  4

  Barbier, M.

  Bottling water, greening farmers: The socio-technical and managerial construction of a 'dispositif' for underground water quality protection
  (2008) International Journal of Agricultural Resources, Governance and Ecology, 7 (1-2), pp. 174-197. Cited 6 times.
  
• 
  5

  Barthélémy, F.
  (2011) Sociologie de l'action organisée. Nouvelles études de cas
  Editions De Boeck, Bruxelles
  

  •  
• 
  6

  Lamine, C., Bellon, S.

  Conversion to organic farming: A multidimensional research object at the crossroads of agricultural and social sciences. A review
  (2009) Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 29 (1), pp. 97-112. Cited 55 times.
  doi: 10.1051/agro:2008007
  
• 
  7

  Bourblanc, M., Crabbé, A., Liefferink, D., Wiering, M.

  The marathon of the hare and the tortoise: implementing the EU Water Framework Directive
  (2013) Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 56 (10), pp. 1449-1467. Cited 4 times.
  doi: 10.1080/09640568.2012.726197
  
• 
  8

  Brochier, D.
  Propositions pour un cadre théorique unifié et une méthodologie d'analyse des trajectoires des projets dans les organisations
  (2010) Management & Avenir, 36 (6), pp. 84-107.
  

  •  
• 
  9

  Busca, D.
  (2010) L'action publique agri-environnementale. La mise en oeuvre négociée des dispositifs. Cited 4 times.
  L'Harmattan, Paris
  

  •  
• 
  10

  Cheng, A.S., Daniels, S.E.

  Getting to "we": Examining the relationship between geographic scale and ingroup emergence in collaborative watershed planning
  (2005) Human Ecology Review, 12 (1), pp. 30-43. Cited 24 times.
  
• 
  11

  Crozier, M., Friedberg, E.
  (1980) Actors & Systems, the Politics of Collective Action. Cited 183 times.
  Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL
  

  •  
• 
  12

  Darnhofer, I., Schneeberger, W., Freyer, B.

  Converting or not converting to organic farming in Austria: Farmer types and their rationale
  (2005) Agriculture and Human Values, 22 (1), pp. 39-52. Cited 95 times.
  doi: 10.1007/s10460-004-7229-9
  
• 
  13

  Faure, A., Pollet, G., Warin, P.
  (1995) La construction du sens dans les politiques publiques. Débats autour de la notion de référentiel. Cited 30 times.
  L'Harmattan, Paris
  

  •  
• 
  14

  Fiquepron, J., Garcia, S., Stenger, A.

  Land use impact on water quality: Valuing forest services in terms of the water supply sector
  (2013) Journal of Environmental Management, 126, pp. 113-121. Cited 8 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2013.04.002
  
• 
  15

  Fleury, P.
  (2011) Agriculture biologique et environnement: des enjeux convergents. Cited 2 times.
  Éducagri éditions-ACTA Publications, Paris
  

  •  
• 
  16

  Foddy, W.
  (1993) Constructing questions for interviews and questionnaires: theory and practice in social research. Cited 350 times.
  Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
  

  •  
• 
  17

  Friedberg, E.
  (1996) Power and Rules: Organizational Dynamics of Collective Action. Cited 4 times.
  Ashgate Publishing Company, Burlington
  

  •  
• 
  18

  Gafsi, M., Brossier, J.

  Farm management and protection of natural resources: Analysis of adaptation process and dependence relationships
  (1997) Agricultural Systems, 55 (1), pp. 71-97. Cited 13 times.
  doi: 10.1016/S0308-521X(96)00079-0
  
• 
  19

  Gosling, P., Shepherd, M.

  Long-term changes in soil fertility in organic arable farming systems in England, with particular reference to phosphorus and potassium
  (2005) Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 105 (1-2), pp. 425-432. Cited 87 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.agee.2004.03.007
  
• 
  20

  Grolleau, G., McCann, L.M.J.

  Designing watershed programs to pay farmers for water quality services: Case studies of Munich and New York City
  (2012) Ecological Economics, 76, pp. 87-94. Cited 16 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.02.006
  
• 
  21

  Haas, G., Berg, M., Köpke, U.

  Nitrate leaching: Comparing conventional, integrated and organic agricultural production systems
  (2002) IAHS-AISH Publication, (273), pp. 131-136. Cited 4 times.
  
• 
  22

  Halberg, N., Steen Kristensen, E., Sillebak Kristensen, I.

  Nitrogen turnover on organic and conventional mixed farms
  (1995) Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 8 (1), pp. 30-51. Cited 68 times.
  doi: 10.1007/BF02286400
  
• 
  23

  Hansen, B., Kristensen, E.S., Grant, R., Høgh-Jensen, H., Simmelsgaard, S.E., Olesen, J.E.

  Nitrogen leaching from conventional versus organic farming systems - A systems modelling approach
  (2000) European Journal of Agronomy, 13 (1), pp. 65-82. Cited 74 times.
  doi: 10.1016/S1161-0301(00)00060-5
  
• 
  24

  Kallis, G., Butler, D.

  The EU water framework directive: Measures and implications
  (2001) Water Policy, 3 (2), pp. 125-142. Cited 174 times.
  doi: 10.1016/S1366-7017(01)00007-1
  
• 
  25

  Kersebaum, K.C., Matzdorf, B., Kiesel, J., Piorr, A., Steidl, J.

  Model-based evaluation of agri-environmental measures in the Federal State of Brandenburg (Germany) concerning N pollution of groundwater and surface water
  (2006) Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science, 169 (3), pp. 352-359. Cited 18 times.
  doi: 10.1002/jpln.200521944
  
• 
  26

  Knudsen, M.T., Kristensen, I.S., Berntsen, J., Petersen, B.M., Kristensen, E.S.

  Estimated N leaching losses for organic and conventional farming in Denmark
  (2006) Journal of Agricultural Science, 144 (2), pp. 135-149. Cited 29 times.
  doi: 10.1017/S0021859605005812
  
• 
  27

  Koontz, T.M., Newig, J.

  Cross-level information and influence in mandated participatory planning: Alternative pathways to sustainable water management in Germany's implementation of the EU water framework directive
  (2014) Land Use Policy, 38, pp. 594-604. Cited 8 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2014.01.005
  
• 
  28

  Korsaeth, A.

  Relations between nitrogen leaching and food productivity in organic and conventional cropping systems in a long-term field study
  (2008) Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 127 (3-4), pp. 177-188. Cited 33 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.agee.2008.03.014
  
• 
  29

  Korsaeth, A., Eltun, R.

  Nitrogen mass balances in conventional, integrated and ecological cropping systems and the relationship between balance calculations and nitrogen runoff in an 8-year field experiment in Norway
  (2000) Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 79 (2-3), pp. 199-214. Cited 66 times.
  doi: 10.1016/S0167-8809(00)00129-8
  
• 
  30

  Lamine, C.

  Transition pathways towards a robust ecologization of agriculture and the need for system redesign. Cases from organic farming and IPM
  (2011) Journal of Rural Studies, 27 (2), pp. 209-219. Cited 34 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2011.02.001
  
• 
  31

  Lamine, C., Bellon, S.
  (2009) Transitions vers l'agriculture biologique. Pratiques et accompagnements pour des systèmes innovants. Cited 5 times.
  Educagri Editions, Paris
  

  •  
• 
  32

  Lascoumes, P., Le Galès, P.
  (2009) Sociologie de l'action publique. Cited 72 times.
  Armand Colin, Paris
  

  •  
• 
  33

  Lerner, D.N., Harris, B.

  The relationship between land use and groundwater resources and quality
  (2009) Land Use Policy, 26 (SUPPL. 1), pp. S265-S273. Cited 47 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2009.09.005
  
• 
  34

  Liefferink, D., Wiering, M., Uitenboogaart, Y.

  The EU Water Framework Directive: A multi-dimensional analysis of implementation and domestic impact
  (2011) Land Use Policy, 28 (4), pp. 712-722. Cited 29 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2010.12.006
  
• 
  35

  Marshall, K., Blackstock, K.L., Dunglinson, J.

  A contextual framework for understanding good practice in integrated catchment management
  (2010) Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 53 (1), pp. 63-89. Cited 17 times.
  doi: 10.1080/09640560903399780
  
• 
  36

  Mondelaers, K., Aertsens, J., van Huylenbroeck, G.

  A meta-analysis of the differences in environmental impacts between organic and conventional farming
  (2009) British Food Journal, 111 (10), pp. 1098-1119. Cited 80 times.
  doi: 10.1108/00070700910992925
  
• 
  37

  Mostert, E., Pahl-Wostl, C., Rees, Y., Searle, B., Tàbara, D., Tippett, J.

  Social learning in European river-basin management: Barriers and fostering mechanisms from 10 river basins
  (2007) Ecology and Society, 12 (1), art. no. 19. Cited 170 times.
  http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol12/iss1/art19/ES-2006-1960.pdf
  
• 
  38

  Muller, P.
  Un schéma d'analyse des politiques sectorielles
  (1985) Revue française de science politique, 35 (2), pp. 165-189. Cited 15 times.
  

  •  
• 
  39

  Musselin, C.

  Organised action sociology and public policies analysis : TWO different approaches for a same object
  (2005) Revue Francaise de Science Politique, 55 (1), pp. 51-71. Cited 14 times.
  doi: 10.3917/rfsp.551.0051
  
• 
  40

  Narcy, J.-B., Mermet, L.

  New justifications for a spatial management of water
  (2003) Natures Sciences Societes, 11 (2), pp. 135-145. Cited 5 times.
  doi: 10.1016/S1240-1307(03)00043-8
  
• 
  41

  Pahl-Wostl, C., Tàbara, D., Bouwen, R., Craps, M., Dewulf, A., Mostert, E., Ridder, D., (...), Taillieu, T.

  The importance of social learning and culture for sustainable water management
  (2008) Ecological Economics, 64 (3), pp. 484-495. Cited 109 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.08.007
  
• 
  42

  Schrack, D., Coquil, X., Ortar, A., Benoît, M.
  Rémanence des pesticides dans les eaux issues de parcelles agricoles récemment converties à l'Agriculture Biologique
  (2009) Innovations Agronomiques, 4, pp. 259-268. Cited 5 times.
  

  •  
• 
  43

  Sohier, C., Degré, A.

  Modelling the effects of the current policy measures in agriculture: An unique model from field to regional scale in Walloon region of Belgium
  (2010) Environmental Science and Policy, 13 (8), pp. 754-765. Cited 10 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.envsci.2010.08.008
  
• 
  44

  Stolze, M., Piorr, A., Häring, A.M., Dabbert, S.
  (2000) Environmental impacts of organic farming in Europe. Cited 27 times.
  University of Hohenheim, Stuttgart-Hohenheim
  

  •  
• 
  45

  Stopes, C., Lord, E.I., Philipps, L., Woodward, L.

  Nitrate leaching from organic farms and conventional farms following best practice
  (2002) Soil Use and Management, 18 (SUPPL.), pp. 256-263. Cited 71 times.
  doi: 10.1079/SUM2002128
  
• 
  46

  Thieu, V., Billen, G., Garnier, J., Benoît, M.

  Nitrogen cycling in a hypothetical scenario of generalised organic agriculture in the Seine, Somme and Scheldt watersheds
  (2011) Regional Environmental Change, 11 (2), pp. 359-370. Cited 21 times.
  doi: 10.1007/s10113-010-0142-4
  
• 
  47

  Thomassen, M.A., van Calker, K.J., Smits, M.C.J., Iepema, G.L., de Boer, I.J.M.

  Life cycle assessment of conventional and organic milk production in the Netherlands
  (2008) Agricultural Systems, 96 (1-3), pp. 95-107. Cited 178 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2007.06.001
  
• 
  48

  Tuomisto, H.L., Hodge, I.D., Riordan, P., Macdonald, D.W.

  Does organic farming reduce environmental impacts? - A meta-analysis of European research
  (2012) Journal of Environmental Management, 112, pp. 309-320. Cited 74 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2012.08.018
  
• 
  49

  Vernoux, J.F., Wuillemier, A., Dörfliger, N.
  (2007) Délimitation des bassins d'alimentation des captages et de leur vulnérabilité vis-à-vis des pollutions diffuses. Guide Méthodologique, p. 75. Cited 2 times.
  BRGM, Paris
  

  •  
• 
  50

  Volk, M., Liersch, S., Schmidt, G.

  Towards the implementation of the European Water Framework Directive?. Lessons learned from water quality simulations in an agricultural watershed
  (2009) Land Use Policy, 26 (3), pp. 580-588. Cited 77 times.
  doi: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2008.08.005
  

  Vincent, A.; ISARA-Lyon, Département ASTER (Agriculture, Systèmes alimentaires et Territoires), Laboratoire d'Etudes Rurales, France
© Copyright 2014 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.